Bethlehem: Bolete (May 2016)

My spouse and I dined at Bolete for dinner on a Saturday night in early May 2016. We booked our table using the Open Table reservation system, but reservations are also available via telephone. Reservations on the weekends are a necessity; we tried to book three different Saturday nights before we found a day that had availability. Bolete is open for dinner Tuesdays through Saturdays and for brunch on Sundays. Parking is available in their own private parking lot (although it is more gravel than asphalt). We have eaten at Bolete several other times over the past few years, primarily for dinner, one time for brunch, and one time for the multi-course chef’s tasting menu (which the restaurant no longer advertises but that was once available only on weeknights). This review describes only our most recent dining experience.

Bolete, which in Latin means “wild mushroom”, opened in 2007 in the space previously occupied by the Inn of the Falcon. Chef Lee Chizmar and his wife Erin own the restaurant. Chizmar was a 2015 James Beard Award semifinalist; he graduated from the Culinary Institute of America and worked for renowned chefs in San Francisco and Boston before opening this Lehigh Valley restaurant. Bolete is housed in a 200-year old building (a former stagecoach inn) located between Fountain Hill and Allentown in Salisbury Township. The restaurant has two areas in which to dine: the main dining room, with tables of various shapes and sizes, and the tavern/bar room, with both tables and bar seating. On the night that we dined, patrons occupied every table and every spot at the bar, which created a bustling atmosphere. The bar is original to the building, and it features brass railings and footrests that are accented by an antique back bar. Bolete is semi-handicap accessible – a ramp to the front door exists, but because it is a centuries-old property, the restrooms are incredibly tiny and could not accommodate a wheelchair. White walls with wide light wood floors, white tablecloths, intentionally mismatched chairs, interesting chandeliers, wall art of mirrors and framed silhouettes, and twig/branch bundles studded with tiny faux butterflies blends well with the rustic setting. The chef and his family live upstairs from the restaurant, so pride of ownership is evident inside and out. Al fresco dining is available in the rear garden in appropriate weather.

Bolete serves upscale American farm-to-table cuisine. The restaurant uses local ingredients whenever possible, and the staff makes all their own stocks, sauces, and pastas, as well as butcher their own meat and fish. The menu offers unique and interesting dishes, components, and ingredients. As appetizers, we ordered the smoked salmon and the asparagus salad. The smoked salmon dish included blinis and roe, whereas the asparagus salad featured greens, bacon pieces, and a poached egg; the chef presented both dishes beautifully. As entrees, we ordered the scallops (which included greens, spring peas, and gnocchi), and the rabbit (which included a mushroom fricassee, greens, and dumplings). The scallops were nicely presented on a regular rectangular white plate, but the rabbit arrived in a two-handled skillet, which was an unusual touch. The delicious yeasty rolls du jour contained spring onion and sea salt; they were so tasty that when our server inquired whether we wanted more, we quickly said “Yes!”. For dessert, we shared the deconstructed banana split, which included a brownie triangle, caramelized bananas, tiny scoops of both chocolate and vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, pistachio brittle/crumbles, and a cherry. It was a great way to end our meal!

Our only criticism with Bolete is that we find the service to be a bit odd. The staff is attentive and available (Bolete is not a restaurant that skimps on its wait staff), but every time that we have dined there, whoever waits on us does this strange thing where they readjust our silverware and other items on our table after they place the first course in front of us. The silverware is already on the table, but the staff takes great care to arrange it precisely on either side of the plate as they have been trained, as well as to minutely adjust anything else (salt cellar, flower vase) that we might have moved from where they feel its precise and rightful place. It just feels like a slap on our hands every time we encounter it – if we choose to move our fork one millimeter too high, no one but us needs to move it back that one millimeter to their liking. On every visit, it makes us feel as if we have done something wrong by touching the items on our table. We have never encountered this service oddity anywhere notable that we have dined (not at The French Laundry or Per Se or Alinea or Daniel or Jean-George or Le Bernardin), so why does Bolete feel the need to tweak our place settings every single time that we have dined there?

Nevertheless, we will return to Bolete, because it is one of the best restaurants that the Lehigh Valley has to offer – excellent quality food in terms of creativity, ingredients, and presentation in an historic setting.













Update February 2017:






October 2018:








No comments: