Allentown PA: Youell's Oyster House (December 2015)

My spouse and I dined at Youell’s Oyster House most recently on a Sunday afternoon in late December 2015 (Christmas weekend). Youell’s is open for dinner daily (and for lunch on special occasions like Mother’s Day and Father’s Day). The restaurant accepts reservations by telephone or using their own computerized reservation system. Complimentary street parking is available.
 
Youell’s is located one block south of Hamilton Street at the corner of 23rd and Walnut Streets. The restaurant has been in operation since the late 1800s. The owners completely renovated and reopened the building after a serious fire in early 2013, and reopened the restaurant in early 2014. The renovation is quite nice, with a large bar (and bar table seating) as well as dining on the street level, with additional dining space on a mezzanine level. The restaurant features a rooftop garden with an apiary for honeybees (the restaurant uses and sells its own honey); disappointingly, no outdoor dining is available although it seems like they have room for it if they so desired. Historically, from the late 1800s to the early 1990s, Youell’s was located in Easton. In the early 1990s, a second location was opened in the West End of Allentown, and two years later, the Easton location was sold and later shuttered.
Youell’s specialty is seafood, and they display a raw bar on their regular bar. Many different types of seafood and combinations are available. If you sit in the bar area, you can choose from the pub menu or the regular dining room menu; whereas if you sit in the dining room, you must order off the dining room menu (not from the pub menu). We have eaten here several times since it re-opened, once in the dining room, and twice in the bar area. On our last visit, we shared the chicken meatballs, which come four to an order, and feature a sort of chicken salad encased in light breading, accompanied by a dipping sauce. These meatballs were not what we expected, and we found them to be a bit heavy (one per person would have been enough, but we each had two). We then ordered the paella and the tacos as entrees. The rice in the paella was moist, whereas most paella rice is a bit dry; it contained a few mussels, a few clams, some white fish, chorizo, and chicken, along with the rice and veggies. (Sadly, two of the large clam shells in the paella arrived completely cracked and broken. We felt that was a quality issue and they should not have been served; however, when we pointed the broken shells out to the bartender who served us, he offered no recourse.) The tacos came three to an order: one chicken, one white fish, and one shrimp. The menu said that the proteins were “all fried tempura style”, although they arrived freshly cooked and sans breading, plus they were extremely spicy from the mango sambal sauce which was too strong to appreciate the broccoli/Brussel sprout/cabbage slaw. For dessert, we shared their amazing Swiss nut cake, which is sort of like a pie filled to the brim with candied walnuts, and accompanied by whipped cream and yummy cinnamon ice cream. This is not the first time that we have enjoyed that nut dessert, and it is so tasty that we are compelled to order it every time that we visit. (Note that the nut pie is a seasonal menu item, served only in the fall and winter.) On previous visits, we have also ordered the combination seafood platter, both fried and broiled (we recommend the broiled over the fried). The restaurant serves warm rolls, accompanied by plenty of butter served in cute clam shells.
We would visit Youell’s more often if it were open for lunch on weekends. We like the variety of the two menus available in the bar area. And the Swiss nut cake should not be missed






No comments: